Late at night in the dark, when we don’t have to look someone straight in the eyes, even our closest friends, the truth has a way of slipping from our lips.
“Honestly, sometimes I wonder what my life would be like if we hadn’t gotten married so young. Or gotten married at all.”
Her voice is shaking. I hear the doubt catch in her throat. As her friend, I want to reach out, hug her close, and tell her it will all be okay — though I have no way of knowing.
Instead, I keep my mouth shut and let her talk.
“Sometimes I think about the guy I dated before him. What if we had ended up together? Or what if I had left home instead of staying here? Would everything be different now? Would everything be better?”
Good friends can sit in the silence together. She has done this for me, too. But in the heavy dark, all I can do is pray for her peace. That she might find whatever she is seeking within the life she has today — or whatever changes might come next.
But I know the weight of this wrestling. For me it often happens when a stranger asks what I studied in college or what I wanted to become when I was younger.
“French and art history,” I answer sheepishly, as if apologizing for the degree now gathering dust. “I thought I was going to teach. Everyone thought I should teach. But I wasn’t sure.”
This is my roundabout way of admitting that my work today has almost nothing to do with the subjects I spent four years studying or the language I spent a decade perfecting. But my life holds good work, holy work, hopeful work I never could have imagined back then. And the many callings I have been given — to marriage, motherhood, friendship, families, and communities — have stretched me in ways I never could have dreamed up in my younger years.
Yet I’m still tempted by alternate versions of my own life, too.
Who hasn’t been distracted by the idle daydream, wondering what-if? What if you had married your high school sweetheart? Or gotten that job and not this one? What if you had switched careers? Or moved across the world? What if you had another child, or none at all?
Alternate versions of our own lives — the what-if ones we might have led — can be as tempting as other people’s experiences.
I’ve even heard the plucky reassurance: “Women can have it all, just not all at once!” But the truth is, we cannot. We have made choices — and had circumstances thrust upon us — that created the contours of one particular life, and no other.
I believe it is good and wise to admit that we can never have it all. Because that truth opens our eyes to see that the one life we do have still holds goodness, beauty, hope, love, and abundance.
You may never be an Olympic athlete. Or a brilliant cook, a talented artist, a best-selling author, or the life of the party. You might never marry your soulmate, raise the family you dreamed of, find the perfect job, or own a place to call your own.
But the more fully you inhabit the life you do have, the more you can come into the presence of God who is fully with you, right here and now.
In his Letter to the Ephesians, Paul speaks to this same truth:
“I, therefore, the prisoner in the Lord, beg you to walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace: there is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all.”
Ephesians 4:1-6 NRSVUE
Paul knew what he was talking about. (He was imprisoned, after all!) Life does not always go the way we hoped or planned. But his words point out the unity we still need within ourselves.
We cannot lead multiple lives: just one. We cannot let regret or distraction consume our thoughts. Right here and now is the real, raw, rough, but beautiful life we have.
The trap comes with thinking that this life is not enough — that we are too small, limited, or powerless to make a difference. But Christ Himself is our hope. This expansive, invigorating, unending hope is enough to fill any life.
You do not need to be more or less. You simply need to be yourself — with God.
“The glory of God is the human person, fully alive,” wrote Irenaeus, a 2nd-century theologian and bishop. When I found his words as a fresh college graduate turning to the work of ministry that now beckoned, I felt my soul leap.
Decades later, his wise words remind me that God dwells fully within and among us — and we glimpse God’s glory most clearly when we are fully alive.
Wherever you are today, the lives you did not lead don’t have to be ghosts that haunt you in the night. And your dreams of what might yet be do not have to become disappointments if they don’t materialize the way you want.
Instead, your one true hope — the “one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all” — can gently remind you that you are living the only life you are called to live.
Because God does not dwell in the lives we did not lead. But in the glory of each one of us, here and now, fully alive.




