O come, O come, Emmanuel
And ransom captive Israel
That mourns in lonely exile here
Until the Son of God appear
Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel
My daughter is sick. It’s serious and it’s mysterious; we don’t know what’s causing it or how to treat it. We’ve tried every avenue available, and nothing has helped. Our hope is wearing thin.
It’s been going on long enough that I’m losing my grip on my belief that God is with us, that He will bring my family strength and healing and peace. It’s been going on long enough that I whispered, just once, in the dark where my kids couldn’t hear, “What if God doesn’t fix this?”
A few years ago when I wrote Create in Me a Heart of Hope, I was searching for reasons to hope when the world is confusing and ugly. After seeing horrible, unexplainable things happen to people I loved, and also watching the news and experiencing the same “unprecedented times” as the rest of the world, my faith was shaken and I found it hard to hope the way I always had before.
Writing that Bible study was a gift and truly saved me in a dark time, bringing me back to what I knew to be true and revealing to me more layers and textures and angles of that Truth than I’d previously understood.
So I know about hope. But it’s one thing to rewrap my arms around hope in a general sense — the kind that feels warm and fuzzy while still having the real bones of what Scripture teaches us about who God is and why He is our hope and how He gives us hope. And it’s another thing altogether to hold on to hope when my actual life is pulling me apart, piece by piece, tossing aside promises I’ve clung to and throwing unanswered prayers (or prayers that get a big fat “no” in response) in my face. It’s hard to hope when I feel like I’m fighting the biggest battle of my life alone.
My daughter is sick for so long that we no longer measure this season in weeks. As I’m writing this, it’s been more than two months.
And I get it! That’s not that long in comparison to a whole lot of things experienced by a whole lot of people. If that’s you, I’m so sorry you’ve been suffering for so long. But as anyone who’s faced trauma knows, when you’re in it, it feels like an eternity. And that feeling is overwhelming, whether your pain started an hour ago, a month ago, a year ago, or a lifetime ago.
I began this calendar year determined to read through the entire Bible chronologically. But a difficult year has taken its toll, and I’ve gotten out of the habit of regularly reading Scripture. The thing about the Bible, though, is that no matter how long we neglect it and no matter how far away we wander, it’s here for us when we return.
I guess it’s like God that way.
A couple weeks ago, the message at church began with the story of Jesus calling Peter and Andrew to follow Him (Luke 5:1-11). The sermon had little to do with hope or trust or healing or hard times. But thinking about those fishermen hearing someone tell them to put their nets out one more time, despite the long hours they’d just spent doing that very thing with no results? And imagining their resignation coupled with the tiniest sliver of hope as they did what He said? And then? When their nets were filled with so many fish it nearly capsized their boat?! Because they’d had just enough hope or, at least obedience, to trust Jesus and try one more time?!
Well, if you think I didn’t sit in that service sobbing like a baby, you would be wrong. At that moment the reason for my hope came flooding back. I remembered those nets full of fish. I remembered the woman who’d been bleeding for more than a decade, reaching for the hem of Jesus’s cloak (Mark 5:25-34), and the religious leader whose daughter had already died (Matthew 9:18-26). I remembered Sarah and Ruth and Hannah and Anna. I remembered the shepherds in the field and the weary world that pined for centuries, waiting for a Savior.
And I remembered the words of a melancholy hymn.
My daughter is still sick, and on the day I’m writing this, I’ve cried a lot of tears. I’m still struggling to hope, but I remember why I hope — and in whom I hope. I know God may continue to say no when I pray (or He may say wait or not yet or not that way). But I’m going to trust that He won’t leave us in this dark place, that He’s never left us. Christmas might be gone for now, but my hope is not — and I will keep singing carols of gloomy clouds of night and lonely exile, while still asking, “O Come, O Come, Emmanuel.”
Are you in a season of waiting? Of pain or confusion? That can make this festive season so much harder, I know. So today I pray that you and I can remember why we hope, that we can join our voices as we fall on our knees in weariness, thankfulness, sadness, and whatever measure of belief we can muster as we sing, “Come.” As we whisper, “Are you still there?”
Lord, be with us.
Ruth Mills says
Mary, thank you for sharing your hard, mysterious health path with your daughter & the struggle to hold onto hope. Your transparency is relatable & also draws me & I’m sure others to join the warriors in prayer for you & your family. Dear Father be tangible to the Carvers & all who are struggling with lost hope/waning hope. Enable us each to be sustained by You the person who is Hope & is faithful in all things even as we waiver. Give insight & wisdom to the medical team to determine & treat Mary’s daughter well or simply say the word & bring healing & restoration. Be magnified in their journey & deepen faith roots for all who witness their journey. In Your Great Name, The Great Physician & Author of Hope, Jesus, Amen.
Carol says
Amen!
Mary Carver says
Ruth, thank you so much for your kindness and your prayer. Thank you for sharing your hope.
mp says
Mary, I’m so very sorry about your daughter’s undiagnosed illness. My heart & prayers go out to you.
My own “hope is wearing thin” story includes an estranged relationship with our son…haven’t had a phone call with him in over 3 years and haven’t seen him in over 5 years.
We’re also going through a difficult “hope is wearing thin” season within our church family.
I need to remember why we have hope and in Whom we have hope.
I even bought your “Create in me a heart of hope” book, but I haven’t even been able to have enough hope to heartbreakingly work my way through it yet.
Praying for more hope.
KathleenB says
Dear mp,
Like you, I’ll be lifting Mary and her family up in healing prayer. Also like you, I have been estranged from my son, without any specific event or explanation since 2012.
My heart goes out to you in your estrangement struggles. Some days my heart is hopeful, while other days I cling to a thread of it. Whether bountiful or lean in hope,
I embrace God’s truth of “all things work together for good for those who love and serve the Lord.”
I envision the Holy Spirit healing my son’s heart. Please know I will pray for your situation to heal. Feel free to reach out to me for further sharing at kathleen.bowers@
comcast.net.
Mary Carver says
mp, that sounds incredibly difficult. I hear your heartbreak in your words. Praying God will give you the glimmer of hope you need to hold on as you endure this “thin” season.
Beth Williams says
MP,
Abba Father, Please shower MP & her family with hope that only comes from you. Soften their son’s heart to call them. Heal their church family. Bring about some peace & calm to their lives. Give MP the strength & will power to go through the “Create in me a Heart of Hope” Bible study. Bless this family as you will. In Jesus Name
Blessings 🙂
Kellie Johnson says
At times in my own life, I have to remind myself that He never leaves. Even if I don’t sense or feel His presence, He is no liar, and so, He is present. Thanks for a glimpse into the real life of most believers. May we always remember that at times, we must remind ourselves, He is God with us.
Kellie
Mary Carver says
Amen, Kellie. What a gift that He is always with us!
Cathy says
My friend had a horrible cancer. She struggled with the pain but was always praying. I know I had thought at times God was not listening or had said no. It is hard to watch and worry about someone. I appreciate your story and knowing others understand how we feel. Thank you
Mary Carver says
Cathy, I’m so sorry for your friend’s—and your—pain. You’re right. Sometimes it’s harder to watch those we love go through pain than it is to feel it ourselves! I suppose that gives us a glimpse into how our pain breaks God’s heart as well.
Susan says
Mary, I will sit and pray for wisdom, compassion and clarity for you, your family and your medical team right now.
I am amazed at the people that muddle through such difficult times and still find the hope that was promised to us.
The day before my mother passed away, her daily calendar saying was “Some day you’ll understand why things happened the way they did”. I feel pretty dense at times. I pray for you to feel and hear God’s presence.
Mary Carver says
Susan, thank you for your kind words and prayer. I’m sometimes dense too. 🙂
Beverly says
Oh Mary, you are so real and I can totally relate to your experiences with your daughter. As tears stream down my face, I pray for you and your daughter as I also pray for my own daughter and her health issues. Reading your words takes away the guilt I often feel for my own thoughts, and you encourage me to remain faithful. I will continue to keep you in my prayers.
Mary Carver says
Beverly, I join you in prayer for our daughters and ourselves. May God heal them and us through this hard journey.
Kelly says
Mary,
I’m sorry that your daughter is sick. I pray that you will get answers and that she will get better soon. Waiting is hard and watching someone we love struggling or hurting or sick is even harder.
Lord , you have the knowledge of what’s going on. Please send relief, the right Doctors , or cure today. Hold on to Mary and her family as they wait and watch. Encourage and strengthen them in every moment. In your Precious Name ,Amen
Laura says
I am in a hope is wearing thin season as well. My daughters who were raised to love Jesus have not had anything to do with Him since living on their own. They are 32 and 28 now and one is raising my grandchild. It’s so heartbreaking to see them living apart from how they were raised and the God who loves them so much. Thank you for sharing your story of struggle. I always look forward to what you have to say. I will be in prayer for your daughter as I continue to pray for mine.
Mary Carver says
Laura, I’m so sorry to hear about your daughters. I join you in prayer for our girls and thank God that He is always with us, always with them.
Lyn says
Mary, my prayers for faith in hope are with you. After several years of hope in faith, and struggles with our oldest; ( as I see others referencing in their responses) and a season of health issues for myself, my hope has become a thinner thread this year. Some days are more overwhelming than others as I grapple with the realities in our lives. I pray that your faith is restored through faith in your beliefs and through the wisdom of the Health system.
We never know when our faith will be tested very personally,
I continue to pray that my faith will guide us through this season
In our lives, as I do for yours. Your words and the comforting , faithful responses from others spoke to me today to keep putting one foot in front of the other toward the light of faith.
Thank you all.
Mary Carver says
Lyn, I’m so sorry to hear that you’re going through a “thin” time as well, but I’m grateful for your kindness and prayer. I join you in asking the Lord to sustain us and heal the hurt places in our families and our lives.
Valerie Grace says
Just this morning, feeling somewhat gloomy about 2023 and so many earthly things weighing upon me, this stanza came to me: “Though Satan should buffet, though trials should come,
let this blest assurance control: that Christ has regarded my helpless estate,and has shed his own blood for my soul.” And I keep reciting that over and over — Christ has regarded MY helpless estate. It IS well with my soul. Prayers are lifted over you Mary that is is well with your soul and for your daughter’s health.
Mary Carver says
It is well. Amen. Thank you for sharing these lyrics, Valerie, and for your prayer!
Anonymous says
Thank you! I needed this today.
Cathy says
Mary, thank you for sharing your struggles. Praying that God just fold His loving arms around you and your daughter. FATHER GOD, I just ask that you heal this your ladies body. Fill her with your peace and help her to rest in You.
Mary Carver says
Thank you, Cathy.
Lauren Griesmeyer says
May the Good Lord heal your daughter and restore your hope in him! I’ve been in a weary time of waiting too! It is so hard! May God give us reason to rejoice in Him yet once again! In Jesus name Amen
Mary Carver says
Thank you for your prayer, Lauren. And yes! May this next season be one of rejoicing aplenty!!
Tara says
Thank you so much for these words Mary. This past year as been the hardest and longest year of my life. From my husband moving out, then asking for a divorce, to me needing to have a total hysterectomy. My hope has definitely been put to the test. I’m praying for a better 2023.
Prayer for your daughter. I pray that she feels better soon.
Mary Carver says
Tara, that is so very much to bear in one short year. Like you, I’m grateful we don’t have to endure our pain alone, grateful we have a Savior who never leaves us. Joining you in prayer today…
Susan says
Testing comes to all while we walk the valleys the unconverted places of our soul and yet Mary your heart is strong and your life stands on an unshakeable foundation (Christ) you will not be moved to the point of no return. There is no other powerful position God gives than to intercede for our daughters, TAKE comfort in the darkest valley, look there is a banquet table prepared – go eat in front of our enemy (Psalms 23).
O come Emmanuel, you are the rod in the valley
O come Emmanuel, you are the staff in the valley
O come Emmanuel, you are the valley
O Emmanuel come take away the offense from our souls while we walk the darkest valley, for all, we walk the victory walk.
O Lord we are all absorbed in thee. Therefore Hope has no end, Praise be to God.
Ann says
Thank you for sharing, Mary. I too have been a long-term medical situation where hope was thin, and I had to cling to Scripture verses on Help and Hope.
And the still small voice asked, “Will you still Follow Me, even through this?”
As time went on there was added, “Will you still Trust Me, even through this?” and, “Will you still Love Me, even through this?” And the only answer had to be Yes. There is nowhere else to go but to the Lord.
Mary Carver says
Yes, Ann, so true – there’s nowhere else to go, nobody else who loves us as much or as well. Your words remind me of my friend Kaitlyn’s book “Even If.” Even if this? Yes, Lord. Yes.
Susan says
Thank you so much
I really needed to hear those words
God bless you
Amen
Paula says
Dear Mary, What a beautiful, open & honest and powerful article! I will be praying for you, your daughter & family! Also for everyone in these comments who has shared such painful situations yet they’re still clinging to the one true God Who gave us Jesus and has the answers for us all as I too continue to daily praise Him even though hard to some days! Our 15 year Navy Veteran son’s lovely unbeliever wife felt she could no longer live the Military life and three years ago left him, taking our two beautiful grandsons, to go further her own career & life. Long story short, he had two breakdowns, lost his career afrter they treated him for trauma and although fighting the divorce for two years it went through yet he has not been allowed to communicate with his boys ages 7 & 9 because of the breakdowns – even after many court hearings and expensive lawyers fees, they make all the decisions not considering or caring he is their flesh & blood Dad. I had forgiven & pray for her (who we had treated as our second daughter) as God taught me to do always, but John III says he no longer believes there’s a God. We haven’t seen him for 4 years and he hasn’t wanted to talk about anything this past year. I have prayed night & day – and for others as I’ve prayed all my life – and shed uncountable tears. One touch, one word from God Whom nothing is impossible can change anything in a moment. I pray that for us all here!
Beth Williams says
Mary,
Abba Father, Give a discerning heart to Mary’s daughter’s medical team. Show them the problem & guide them to the proper treatment. Send your healing touch. Give the family hope & peace in the midst of this trial. In Jesus Name
I work in ICU as a clerical. I see traumas & families in despair every day. I pray for them just as I did for you. Asking God to comfort them with the hope that only comes from Him. Life is hard down here. But one day we will all understand why things happened as they did.
Blessings 🙂
Donna says
Praying that the Lord would hold you and you family close at this difficult time, that he would encourage all of you, that he would reach out to each of you in a very personal way, that he would restore your hope, that he would give the doctors wisdom and that he would heal your daughter. I pray that God will lift you up and carry you when your own strength is gone and that he will show himself faithful and shower you with His love.
Tami says
I’ve been exactly where you are. Hang in there. Keep being her advocate. We will keep her (and your family) in our prayers!!
Becky Miller says
Thank you. This may have been written weeks ago but it came at just the right time for me.